Discuss whether natural resources are a blessing or a curse for developing economies.
4.3.2
Blessing in Botswana- Per-head growth of 7.7% a year (1965–98), fastest in the world.
- Diamond revenue paid for schools, clinics, roads and HIV treatment.
- No civil conflict; low corruption by regional standards.
Signs of a curse- ~75% of exports from one product; recession when it slumps.
- Unemployment 27.6%; Gini ~0.53.
- Weak diversification after 50 years.
ChainDiamond exports → large tax and dividend revenue → government invests in education and infrastructure → human capital and productivity rise → LRAS shifts right.
JudgmentResources are a blessing when institutions are strong and revenue is saved and invested. Even then, they do not create jobs or diversify an economy on their own. Compare with Nigeria.
Evaluate the importance of institutions and good governance for economic development.
4.3.2
Very important- Secure property rights and the rule of law since 1966.
- Elites with cattle and land interests backed growth.
- Peaceful handover of power in 2024 after 58 years.
Not enough alone- Good institutions did not deliver diversification or jobs.
- Diamond luck: some of the richest deposits on earth.
- Fiscal rules breached in the 2025 slump.
ChainSecure property rights and honest government → firms and De Beers willing to invest long term → revenue used for public goods, not stolen → sustained growth.
JudgmentInstitutions explain why Botswana differs from other resource exporters. They are necessary but not sufficient: geography, a small market and skills also matter.
Evaluate the use of a sovereign wealth fund to manage revenue from natural resources.
4.3.3 · 4.5
Benefits- Pula Fund saved windfalls abroad, limiting Dutch disease.
- Smoothed spending through the 2009 and 2020 shocks.
- Saves for when diamonds run out.
Limits- Government's balance run down since the 2014 peak.
- Reserves fell from 18.3 to ~6 months of imports.
- Money saved abroad is not invested in jobs at home.
ChainDiamond boom → revenue saved abroad, not spent at home → less pressure on the pula and domestic prices → other exporters stay competitive → buffer available in a slump.
JudgmentA fund works only with a rule that forces saving in booms. Botswana's fund was too small relative to repeated shocks. Norway's larger fund and strict spending rule show the contrast.
Assess the effects of a fall in the world price of a country's main export.
4.1.4 · 2.1.4
Severe effects- GDP −2.8% (2024) and about −0.4% (2025).
- Budget deficit 9.3% of GDP; medicine shortages.
- Reserves and the current account weakened.
Cushioned- Savings and low debt gave room to borrow.
- Pula crawl adjusts competitiveness gradually.
- Output recovering in 2026 (+43% H1 Debswana).
ChainDiamond prices fall → terms of trade worsen → export revenue and mining output fall → government revenue falls → spending cuts or borrowing → AD falls via the multiplier.
JudgmentDepends on how long the fall lasts and the size of buffers. A cyclical fall can be smoothed; a structural fall from lab-grown competition needs the economy to change.
Evaluate policies a government could use to diversify its economy.
4.3.3
Could work- Beneficiation: diamond sales moved to Gaborone (2013).
- Copper mines in the Kalahari Copper Belt.
- High-value tourism in the Okavango Delta.
Limits- Small market of ~2.5 m people; landlocked.
- Competition from South African manufacturers.
- Plans since the 1980s achieved little; tourism still ~5% of GDP.
ChainInvest diamond revenue in skills and infrastructure → new sectors become competitive → exports broaden → less exposure to one price → more stable growth and jobs.
JudgmentDiversifying within resources (copper) and resource-linked services is more realistic than mass manufacturing. Success depends on skills and regional trade access.
To what extent does rapid economic growth raise living standards for everyone?
4.3.1 · 4.2.2
It did- From one of the poorest countries to upper-middle income.
- Poverty fell to 16.3% (2015/16).
- Free education, clinics and HIV treatment.
Not for everyone- Gini ~0.53, among the world's highest.
- Youth unemployment 38.2%.
- HIV/AIDS cut life expectancy despite growth.
ChainGDP rises from mining → revenue to the state, profits to a few → few jobs created → incomes rise for public and formal workers → inequality stays high.
JudgmentThe type of growth matters. Capital-intensive growth raises average income but spreads it narrowly, so GDP per head overstates typical living standards. Use HDI and Gini alongside GDP.
Assess the causes of high unemployment in an upper-middle-income economy.
2.1.3
Structural causes- Mining employs ~2% of workers despite dominating output.
- Graduates' skills do not match available jobs.
- Small private sector; the state is the main employer.
Other causes- Cyclical: mine job losses in the 2024–25 slump.
- Drought hits rural jobs.
- Competition from South African firms.
ChainGrowth led by capital-intensive mining → little demand for labour (derived demand) → school leavers and graduates outnumber jobs → structural unemployment.
JudgmentMainly structural, so demand-side stimulus helps little. Supply-side policies (skills, private-sector growth) matter more but act slowly.
Evaluate how a government should respond to a sharp fall in tax revenue.
4.5.3 · 2.6.2
Borrow and smooth- Debt only 33% of GDP (Dec 2025), so room existed.
- Cuts in a recession deepen it via the multiplier.
- Revenue may recover as diamond output rises.
Cut and adjust- Debt heading above the 40% ceiling; ratings cut.
- A structural fall in diamond demand will not reverse.
- Arrears to suppliers caused medicine shortages.
ChainMineral revenue falls → deficit widens to 9.3% of GDP → borrowing rises → credit rating downgraded → higher interest costs and less fiscal space.
JudgmentDepends on whether the shock is temporary or permanent. Borrowing suits a temporary fall; a permanent one needs new revenue sources and spending reform.
Evaluate a pegged exchange rate for a small open economy.
4.1.8
Benefits- Stability against the rand, as most imports come from South Africa.
- Kept inflation low for years (2.7% in 2025).
- Crawl allows gradual adjustment.
Costs- Needs reserves, which have fallen.
- Faster crawl in 2025 added to 2026 inflation.
- Pula can be overvalued if diamonds boom.
ChainFaster downward crawl → pula weaker against the basket → non-diamond exports more competitive, imports dearer → current account improves but cost-push inflation rises.
JudgmentA crawling basket peg suits a small, import-dependent economy. It works only while reserves and fiscal policy back it.
Assess the impact of health on economic development.
4.3.2
Large impact- HIV cut life expectancy and the workforce in the 1990s–2000s.
- Prevalence still 15.7% (2024).
- Health spending diverts funds from other investment.
Can be managed- Free ARVs since 2002 restored life expectancy.
- Growth continued through the epidemic.
- Botswana is a world leader in HIV treatment coverage.
ChainHigh HIV prevalence → working-age deaths and illness → smaller, less productive labour force → lower LRAS and more health spending → slower development.
JudgmentHealth shocks can reverse development gains, but a well-funded state can limit the damage. Resource revenue made Botswana's response possible.