ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
UK house prices fall after a long period of rising faster than incomes.
1
As a result, the wealth of homeowners falls, and homeowners, particularly older and higher-income households who own outright or own several properties, hold a large share of total wealth.
wealth inequality
wealth inequality
Assumes: Housing makes up a large share of wealth held by richer households.
But: For the very richest, financial assets matter more than housing, so a fall in house prices may hit middle-wealth homeowners hardest.
2
This means the gap in wealth between homeowners and renters narrows.
distribution of wealth
distribution of wealth
Assumes: Renters hold little housing wealth.
But: Renters' own savings may also fall in value if the house price fall is part of a wider financial crisis.
3
In addition, the ratio of house prices to incomes falls, so homes become more affordable for young people and lower-income first-time buyers.
affordability · house price to income ratio
affordability · house price to income ratio
Best link to attack
Assumes: First-time buyers can obtain mortgages.
Assumes: First-time buyers can obtain mortgages.
But: If banks tighten lending and demand larger deposits as house prices fall, as after 2008, first-time buyers may be unable to buy despite lower prices.
4
Therefore, wealth inequality narrows, both between owners and renters and between older and younger generations.
wealth inequality · intergenerational inequality
wealth inequality · intergenerational inequality
Assumes: Recent buyers are not pushed into negative equity.
But: Young buyers who bought near the peak with small deposits may fall into negative equity, which hits less wealthy households hardest.
End
Wealth inequality may narrow, but only if lower prices actually let renters and first-time buyers buy.
Evaluation chain
- E1However, whether young people and renters gain depends on their being able to get a mortgage.
- E2If banks respond to falling house prices by requiring larger deposits and cutting high loan-to-value mortgages, then many first-time buyers cannot buy even at lower prices.
- E3As a result, wealth stays concentrated among existing owners and cash buyers, who can buy property cheaply.
- E4So falling house prices may narrow wealth inequality much less than expected, and can even widen it if wealthier buyers take advantage of lower prices.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chainMembers can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Questions this answers
- Assess the impact of a fall in house prices on the distribution of wealth.
- Explain the difference between income inequality and wealth inequality, using housing as an example.
- Discuss whether falling house prices benefit younger generations.
Diagram
No standard diagram. A Lorenz curve for wealth moving towards the line of equality, or data on home ownership by age, makes good support.
Reverse and related
Rise in house prices → homeowners' wealth rises and homes become less affordable, so wealth inequality between owners and renters widens.