Chain of analysis · Poverty and inequality

Higher welfare benefits → Growth

Edexcel 9EC0 2.6 · 4.5.1AQA A level 4.2.5.1
ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
The government raises welfare benefits, for example increasing Universal Credit, and funds the rise by borrowing.
1
As a result, the cash incomes of households receiving benefits rise, and these households are concentrated in the bottom income groups.
transfer payments · means-tested benefits
Assumes: Eligible households claim the benefits they are entitled to.
But: Many eligible households never claim means-tested benefits because of stigma or a complex application, so some of the poorest miss out.
2
Since low-income households have a high marginal propensity to consume, they spend most of the extra income on goods and services.
marginal propensity to consume
Assumes: Recipients spend the money rather than save it or repay debt.
But: Households with large debts or arrears may use the money to pay them off, so less of it is spent on current output.
3
As a result, consumption rises and aggregate demand shifts to the right.
consumption · aggregate demand
Assumes: The rise is not paid for by an equal rise in other taxes.
But: If it is funded by higher taxes on richer households, their spending falls too, although by less than recipients' spending rises because the rich have a lower MPC.
4
Consequently, firms see higher sales, take on more output, and the multiplier raises national income by more than the initial injection, so real GDP rises in the short run.
multiplier · real GDP
Best link to attack
Assumes: There is spare capacity in the economy.
But: If the economy is close to full capacity, higher AD mainly pulls up the price level and real output rises very little.
End
Aggregate demand rises and short-run economic growth increases, especially when there is spare capacity.
Evaluation chainattacks link 4 · Assumptions
  1. E1However, the boost to real GDP depends on how much spare capacity exists when benefits rise.
  2. E2If the economy is already close to full employment, then firms cannot easily raise output to meet the extra demand.
  3. E3As a result, the extra spending pulls up prices, and the real value of the benefit rise is partly eroded by inflation.
  4. E4So the growth effect is large in a recession with a negative output gap and small when the economy is already at or above capacity.
Another way to attack it: Long-run growth depends on aggregate supply. If higher benefits weaken the incentive to work, labour supply and LRAS grow more slowly; if they cut child poverty, better health and education may raise future productivity.

Once paid, the extra income is spent quickly, so the effect on AD comes sooner than with capital projects that take years to plan.

Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chain

Questions this answers

  • Assess the impact of an increase in welfare benefits on economic growth.
  • Discuss whether raising benefits is an effective way to boost aggregate demand in a recession.
  • Explain why the size of the multiplier depends on who receives extra income.

Diagram

AD/AS diagram: AD shifts right. With spare capacity, real GDP rises with little change in the price level; near full capacity, the price level rises more than output.

Reverse and related

Benefit cut → low-income households spend less → AD and short-run growth fall, with a large multiplier effect because their MPC is high.

GCSE version

  1. StartThe government gives more money in benefits and borrows to pay for it.
  2. 1Poorer families get more money in benefits.
  3. 2They spend almost all of it in shops and on services.
  4. 3Firms sell more and produce more, so the economy grows.

← All chains in the Chain Bank