Chain of analysis · Government intervention

Indirect tax → Market failure

Edexcel 9EC0 1.4.1 · 1.3.2AQA AS 3.1.5AQA A level 4.1.8iGCSE 4EC1 · externalitiesOCR J205 · externalities
ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
The government imposes an indirect tax on a good whose consumption creates external costs, for example the Soft Drinks Industry Levy on sugary drinks, which are linked to obesity and its costs to the NHS.
1
As a result, the tax adds to the private cost of supplying each unit, so the MPC curve shifts up towards the MSC curve.
MPC · MSC
Assumes: The tax falls on the activity causing the external cost.
But: If most harm comes from heavy consumption by a minority, a tax on every unit also falls on moderate consumers who cause little harm.
2
This means the external cost is internalised: buyers and sellers now face a price closer to the full social cost.
internalising the externality
Assumes: The tax is passed on in the price.
But: If producers absorb most of the tax, the price consumers see changes little, so their choices change little.
3
Consequently, output falls from the free-market level towards the social optimum where MSB equals MSC.
social optimum · allocative efficiency
Assumes: Demand responds to the higher price.
But: Demand for habit-forming goods is often price inelastic, so output falls only a little.
4
Therefore, the welfare loss triangle shrinks, and disappears if the tax equals the marginal external cost at the social optimum.
welfare loss · marginal external cost
Best link to attack
Assumes: The government can measure the marginal external cost.
But: External costs such as future health costs are hard to value in money, so the tax may be set too low, leaving a welfare loss, or too high, creating a new one.
End
Output moves towards the social optimum and the welfare loss falls, removed entirely only if the tax equals the marginal external cost.
Evaluation chainattacks link 4 · Assumptions
  1. E1However, the welfare loss is removed only if the tax is set equal to the marginal external cost.
  2. E2Because the external costs of obesity are spread over many years and have many causes, the government cannot measure them accurately.
  3. E3As a result, the tax is likely to be set at a rough level, too low to reach the social optimum or high enough to push output below it.
  4. E4So the tax moves output towards the social optimum and reduces the welfare loss, but it is unlikely to remove it exactly.
Another way to attack it: If demand is very price inelastic, output falls little and the tax mainly raises revenue; spending that revenue on education or treatment may then do more to reduce the externality than the tax itself.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chain

Questions this answers

  • Explain, using a diagram, how an indirect tax can correct a negative externality.
  • Assess the effectiveness of an indirect tax in reducing the consumption of a demerit good.
  • Evaluate the case for taxing sugary drinks to correct market failure.

Diagram

MPC and MSC with demand (MPB = MSB). The free market produces Q1 where MPC = MPB, above Q* where MSC = MSB; the welfare loss triangle lies between Q1 and Q*. The tax shifts MPC up to MPC + tax; if the tax equals the marginal external cost at Q*, output falls to Q* and the triangle disappears. For a consumption externality, draw MSB below MPB instead.

Reverse and related

Cutting or removing the tax → MPC falls, output rises back above the social optimum and the welfare loss returns.

GCSE version

  1. StartThe government puts a tax on sugary drinks.
  2. 1The tax makes the harmful product more expensive.
  3. 2People buy less of it.
  4. 3So the harm to other people, such as health costs, falls.

← All chains in the Chain Bank