ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
A multinational mining or manufacturing company sets up operations in a developing economy with a narrow tax base.
1
As a result, the company pays corporation tax on its profits, and its workers pay income tax on their wages.
tax revenue · corporation tax
tax revenue · corporation tax
Assumes: The government collects tax on the multinational's activities.
But: Governments often offer tax holidays and low rates to attract FDI, so little tax is paid in the early years.
2
This means government revenue rises without raising tax rates, and the formal sector the multinational creates is easier to tax than informal activity.
tax base · informal sector
tax base · informal sector
Assumes: Workers and suppliers move into the formal, taxed economy.
But: Local suppliers may remain informal and outside the tax net.
3
At the same time, multinationals can shift profits to subsidiaries in low-tax countries by setting the prices they charge themselves for inputs, brands and loans.
transfer pricing · tax avoidance
transfer pricing · tax avoidance
Best link to attack
Assumes: Profits are declared in the country where the production takes place.
Assumes: Profits are declared in the country where the production takes place.
But: Where tax authorities are well resourced and international rules on profit shifting are enforced, more of the profit is taxed locally.
4
Therefore, the budget deficit narrows by the extra tax collected, less any spending on infrastructure or subsidies used to attract the investment.
budget deficit · fiscal balance
budget deficit · fiscal balance
Assumes: The government did not spend heavily to win the investment.
But: Spending on roads, ports and grants to attract the multinational can outweigh the tax it pays for many years.
End
The fiscal balance improves through higher tax revenue, by less than expected if tax incentives and profit shifting reduce what is collected.
Evaluation chain
- E1However, the gain in revenue depends on the multinational declaring its profits in the host country.
- E2If it charges its local subsidiary high prices for brand licences, loans and components from a sister company in a low-tax country, local profits look small.
- E3As a result, little corporation tax is paid locally, and developing countries often lack the tax officials to challenge these prices.
- E4So the improvement in the fiscal balance may be small, and could be negative if the government also spent heavily to attract the investment.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chainMembers can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Questions this answers
- Assess the extent to which FDI improves the public finances of developing countries.
- Discuss whether governments should offer tax incentives to attract multinationals.
- Explain how transfer pricing can reduce the benefits of FDI to a host country.
Diagram
No standard diagram. Use the budget balance: tax revenue minus government spending, noting any incentives offered.
Reverse and related
Multinational leaves → corporation and income tax revenue lost, so the deficit widens.