ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
The Monetary Policy Committee cuts Bank Rate, for example from 5% to 4%, and commercial banks lower the interest rates they charge on business loans.
1
As a result, the cost of borrowing to pay for new machinery, buildings and technology falls for firms.
cost of borrowing · transmission mechanism
cost of borrowing · transmission mechanism
Assumes: Banks pass the lower Bank Rate on to business loans.
But: In a financial crisis banks may keep lending rates high or refuse to lend to riskier firms, so the cut does not reach many small businesses.
2
This means more investment projects have an expected rate of return above the cost of financing them, so projects that were not worthwhile before become profitable.
marginal efficiency of capital · rate of return
marginal efficiency of capital · rate of return
Assumes: Firms decide whether to invest by comparing the expected return with the interest rate.
But: Firms that use a payback period or a hurdle rate well above the interest rate may not change their decisions after a small cut.
3
In addition, the interest firms can earn by leaving retained profits in the bank falls, so the opportunity cost of using those profits for investment falls.
opportunity cost · retained profits
opportunity cost · retained profits
Assumes: Firms compare the return on investment with what their retained profits could earn elsewhere.
But: Firms that are worried about the future may prefer to hold cash or pay off debt, whatever the interest rate.
4
Consequently, firms bring forward or start new projects, so investment rises.
interest elasticity of investment · business confidence
interest elasticity of investment · business confidence
Best link to attack
Assumes: Firms are confident that demand will be strong enough to use the extra capacity.
Assumes: Firms are confident that demand will be strong enough to use the extra capacity.
But: Rates are usually cut when the economy is weak, and firms with spare capacity that expect sales to fall have no reason to build more, however cheap borrowing becomes.
End
Investment rises, as long as firms expect enough demand to use the new capacity.
Evaluation chain
- E1However, the rise in investment depends on firms being confident that demand will be strong enough to use the extra capacity.
- E2When rates are cut because the economy is heading into recession, firms often have spare capacity and expect sales to fall, so they have no need for new machines or buildings however cheap borrowing becomes.
- E3As a result, falling confidence shifts the investment demand curve to the left at the same time as the lower rate moves firms along it, as in 2009, when business investment fell sharply even though Bank Rate had been cut to 0.5%.
- E4So a rate cut raises investment most when confidence is already recovering, and may do little to raise investment in a deep downturn.
Another way to attack it: Rate cuts lose their power when Bank Rate is already close to zero, which is why the Bank of England turned to quantitative easing in 2009.
Time lag: projects take months to plan, approve and start, so the rise in investment builds up gradually.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chainMembers can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Questions this answers
- Explain how a cut in interest rates might increase investment.
- Assess whether lower interest rates are likely to raise business investment during a recession.
- Discuss the effectiveness of interest rate cuts in encouraging firms to invest.
Diagram
Investment demand (MEC) diagram: a cut from r1 to r2 is a movement down along the curve, so investment rises from I1 to I2. If confidence falls at the same time, the whole curve shifts left and investment may not rise.
Reverse and related
Interest rate rise → investment falls.