ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
The Monetary Policy Committee raises Bank Rate, for example from 4% to 5%, and commercial banks raise the interest rates they charge on business loans.
1
As a result, the cost of borrowing to pay for new machinery, buildings and technology rises for firms.
cost of borrowing · transmission mechanism
cost of borrowing · transmission mechanism
Assumes: Banks pass the higher Bank Rate on to business loans.
But: Firms with fixed-rate loans are unaffected until the loans are renewed, and banks competing for business customers may raise loan rates by less than Bank Rate.
2
This means fewer investment projects have an expected rate of return above the cost of financing them, so projects that were only just worthwhile are no longer profitable.
marginal efficiency of capital · rate of return
marginal efficiency of capital · rate of return
Assumes: Firms decide whether to invest by comparing the expected return with the interest rate.
But: Many firms judge projects with a payback period or a hurdle rate well above the interest rate, and expected sales and confidence matter far more than a one-point change in rates.
3
In addition, firms that pay for investment out of retained profits face a higher opportunity cost, because that money could now earn more in the bank or be used to pay off debt.
opportunity cost · retained profits
opportunity cost · retained profits
Assumes: Firms compare the return on investment with what their retained profits could earn elsewhere.
But: Retained profits are usually the cheapest and easiest source of finance, so firms with strong cash flow may go ahead with projects whatever happens to rates.
4
Consequently, firms postpone or cancel projects, especially long-lived ones such as new factories where the extra interest builds up over many years, so the level of investment falls.
interest elasticity of investment
interest elasticity of investment
Assumes: Nothing else is pushing investment up at the same time.
But: If sales are growing and the firm is close to full capacity, it may still need to expand, so the accelerator effect can outweigh the higher cost of borrowing.
5
Since investment is a component of aggregate demand (AD = C + I + G + X − M), AD shifts to the left.
components of aggregate demand
components of aggregate demand
Best link to attack
Assumes: Investment is a large enough share of AD for its fall to move AD noticeably.
Assumes: Investment is a large enough share of AD for its fall to move AD noticeably.
But: Investment is less than a fifth of UK GDP, while household consumption is over 60%, so the investment route on its own shifts AD only a little.
6
Consequently, firms that make capital goods, such as construction and machinery firms, receive fewer orders and cut output and jobs, so through the multiplier national income falls by more than the first fall in investment.
multiplier
multiplier
Assumes: Most of the lost income would have been spent on domestic output.
But: The UK has high leakages into imports, saving and tax, so each later round of lost spending is small and the multiplier is fairly small.
7
In addition, as output and expected sales fall, firms need less new capacity, so they cut investment further through the accelerator, pushing AD further to the left.
accelerator
accelerator
Assumes: Firms expect the fall in sales to last.
But: Firms that see the slowdown as temporary keep their long-term investment plans, so the accelerator effect is weak.
End
AD shifts to the left, and national income falls by more than the first fall in investment.
Evaluation chain
- E1However, the size of the shift in AD depends on how large investment is as a share of aggregate demand.
- E2Because investment makes up less than a fifth of UK GDP, while household consumption makes up over 60%, even a sizeable percentage fall in investment is a small share of total spending.
- E3As a result, the investment route on its own moves AD only a little, although investment is the most volatile component of AD and can swing more sharply than consumption.
- E4So the fall in AD from a rate rise depends mainly on how households respond, and AD falls by much more when higher rates also cut consumption and net exports.
Another way to attack it: A rate rise also reduces consumption (dearer credit, higher mortgage payments, a bigger reward for saving) and net exports (a stronger pound), so the total fall in AD is larger than the investment route alone.
Time lag: investment plans change slowly and the multiplier works through several rounds of spending, so the full fall in AD takes many months.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chainMembers can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Questions this answers
- Using an AD/AS diagram, explain how a rise in interest rates might affect aggregate demand.
- Assess the extent to which an increase in interest rates will reduce aggregate demand.
- Examine how a change in investment can lead to a larger change in national income.
Diagram
AD/AS: AD shifts left from AD1 to AD2; real output falls from Y1 to Y2 and the price level falls from P1 to P2 (or rises more slowly). An investment demand (MEC) diagram can show the first step.
Reverse and related
Interest rate cut → AD rises.