ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
The government makes income tax more progressive, for example raising the 45% additional rate or lowering the income at which higher rates begin.
1
As a result, the post-tax wage for each extra hour worked by high earners falls.
marginal tax rate · net wage
marginal tax rate · net wage
Assumes: The higher rate applies to the extra income of people deciding how much to work.
But: Many high earners are salaried with fixed contracts, so their hours do not depend on the reward for each extra hour.
2
This means leisure becomes relatively cheaper, so through the substitution effect some high earners work fewer hours, retire earlier or turn down promotion.
substitution effect · income effect
substitution effect · income effect
Best link to attack
Assumes: The substitution effect outweighs the income effect.
Assumes: The substitution effect outweighs the income effect.
But: Through the income effect, some high earners work more to keep up their post-tax income, so total hours may not fall.
3
Consequently, the supply of skilled labour falls, and some high earners and their businesses may move abroad.
supply of labour · migration
supply of labour · migration
Assumes: High earners are internationally mobile.
But: Most people are tied to their country by family, language and career, so few actually emigrate for tax reasons.
4
Therefore, firms that rely on skilled staff and entrepreneurs hire fewer complementary workers, so employment grows more slowly.
derived demand
derived demand
Assumes: Skilled and less-skilled labour are complements.
But: Departing high earners are often replaced quickly by others keen to take their roles, so employment elsewhere is little affected.
End
Labour supply at the top falls and employment grows more slowly than it otherwise would.
Evaluation chain
- E1However, the effect on hours worked depends on whether the substitution effect outweighs the income effect.
- E2If high earners have fixed commitments such as mortgages and school fees, then a lower post-tax wage may push them to work more to keep their income.
- E3As a result, total hours supplied by high earners may change very little.
- E4So a more progressive tax has a small effect on employment overall, with larger effects only among the most internationally mobile workers.
Another way to attack it: If the extra revenue funds childcare, training or in-work support, labour supply at the lower end may rise, offsetting any fall at the top.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chainMembers can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Questions this answers
- Assess the impact of higher marginal income tax rates on labour supply.
- Discuss whether progressive taxes reduce incentives to work.
- Explain the income and substitution effects of a rise in income tax.
Diagram
Labour market diagram: the supply curve of skilled labour shifts left, raising gross wages and reducing employment in that market. A backward-bending supply curve can show where the income effect dominates.
Reverse and related
Cut in the top rate → higher reward for extra work → hours and entrepreneurship may rise, although the income effect may lead some to work less.