ChainWhat it assumes · how to break it
Start
A young person stays in education to take A levels and a degree, gaining skills that benefit others as well as themselves.
1
As a result, the educated worker is more productive, which raises output for employers and helps colleagues work more effectively.
human capital · external benefit
human capital · external benefit
Best link to attack
Assumes: Education raises productivity.
Assumes: Education raises productivity.
But: If qualifications mainly signal ability the worker already had, employers gain little extra output from the education itself.
2
In addition, educated people are more likely to be in work and to earn more, so they pay more tax and claim fewer benefits.
external benefit · tax revenue
external benefit · tax revenue
Assumes: Higher earnings follow from the education.
But: Graduates in low-paid jobs may earn little more than non-graduates, so the extra tax they pay is small.
3
Consequently, taxpayers gain because more revenue is available for public services without higher tax rates.
external benefit · public finances
external benefit · public finances
Assumes: The extra revenue is spent on services others use.
But: If education is funded by the state, part of the gain to taxpayers is offset by its cost.
4
Therefore, third parties such as firms, taxpayers and the wider community gain benefits from education they did not pay for.
positive externality · third parties
positive externality · third parties
Assumes: These benefits are not already reflected in the student's own reward.
But: Much of the productivity gain is paid to the worker as higher wages, which is a private benefit.
End
Third parties, including employers, colleagues and taxpayers, gain benefits from education that they did not pay for.
Evaluation chain
- E1However, the benefit to third parties depends on education actually raising productivity.
- E2If qualifications mainly signal ability that workers already had, employers use them to sort applicants without the education raising output.
- E3As a result, the extra output for firms and colleagues is small, and most of the gain goes to the individual as a better-paid job.
- E4So the benefit to third parties may be smaller than claimed for advanced qualifications, though basic literacy and numeracy clearly raise productivity and so benefit others.
Can you say this chain from memory?
Members can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Practise this chainMembers can hide the links, test themselves and track which chains they have mastered.
Questions this answers
- Explain two external benefits of education.
- Analyse how the consumption of a merit good benefits people outside the market.
- Discuss whether the benefits of higher education go mainly to the student or to society.
Diagram
MSB above MPB, with MPC = MSC (supply): market output Q1 where MPB = MPC, social optimum Q* where MSB = MSC, so Q1 < Q*. The vertical gap between MSB and MPB is the external benefit per unit gained by third parties.
Reverse and related
Negative consumption externality → third parties bear costs they did not choose, e.g. second-hand smoke.